Spider-Man: Brand New Day Post-Credits Explained – Is Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, or a New Spider-Man Coming?

Spider-Man: Brand New Day Post-Credits Explained: Is Another Spider-Man Coming? Tobey, Andrew, or a Brand-New Multiverse Hero?

⚠️ SPOILER WARNING: If you haven't watched Spider-Man: Brand New Day yet... this is your last chance to swing away. Seriously.

Marvel fans have officially entered detective mode.

Ever since the final post-credit scene dropped, social media has exploded with one giant question:

Who is that Spider-Man?

Is it Tom Holland?

Is Marvel secretly bringing back Tobey Maguire?

Could Andrew Garfield finally return?

Or... are we about to meet an entirely new Spider-Man from another universe?

Let's break it all down.

The Biggest Clue: Why Did the Spider Tracker Glitch?

The post-credit scene looks surprisingly simple at first.

Ned's Spider Tracker suddenly activates, zooms out, glitches several times, and finally locks onto a Spider-Man signal that doesn't appear to be on Earth.

Then...

"Spider-Man Will Return."

That's it.

No explanation.

No identity reveal.

Just enough to send the entire internet into absolute chaos.

Theory #1: It's Still Tom Holland's Spider-Man

This is currently the safest interpretation.

Several entertainment outlets believe the tracker is following Peter Parker himself, suggesting he has somehow been transported off Earth—or even into another reality—as Marvel begins setting up its next Multiverse storyline.

If that's true, Brand New Day isn't introducing another Spider-Man.

It's simply teasing Peter Parker's next adventure.

Theory #2: Tobey Maguire Is Back

Now here's where things get spicy.

A huge section of the Marvel community believes the signal isn't Tom Holland at all.

Instead, they think it's Peter Parker from another universe, possibly Tobey Maguire's legendary Spider-Man.

Why?

Because the tracker glitches before locking onto the signal, making fans wonder if it's detecting someone outside the current universe rather than Peter from Earth-616.

This idea has gained traction across Reddit, although it's important to note that Marvel has not confirmed it.

Theory #3: Andrew Garfield Isn't Done Yet

Andrew Garfield remains one of the MCU fandom's biggest "please make it happen" requests.

Ever since No Way Home, fans have wanted his Spider-Man to return for another major storyline.

Could Brand New Day be quietly setting that up?

Maybe.

But once again, there's no official confirmation that Andrew Garfield appears—or is being teased—in the post-credit scene.

At the moment, it's pure speculation fueled by the Multiverse Saga and fans connecting dots that may or may not exist.

Still... Marvel knows exactly how to keep fans guessing.

Theory #4: A Completely New Spider-Man

This theory might actually be the most interesting.

Some fans believe the mysterious signal belongs to an entirely different Spider-Man, not Tom, Tobey, or Andrew.

That could mean:

• A Spider-Man from another universe
• A future Spider-Man
• A variant we've never met before
• Or someone connected to Marvel's upcoming Multiverse events

The film never identifies the owner of the signal, leaving the door wide open for future surprises.

Is Marvel Setting Up Avengers: Doomsday?

Honestly...

It feels that way.

Marvel has already confirmed the post-credit scene serves as a bridge toward Spider-Man's future, while several industry reports have connected it to the next major Avengers storyline.

Whether that's Avengers: Doomsday, Secret Wars, or something even bigger, the message is pretty clear:

Spider-Man's story is far from over.

So... Will Tobey or Andrew Actually Return?

Here's the honest answer.

Nobody knows yet.

There is no official confirmation that Tobey Maguire or Andrew Garfield will appear in the next Spider-Man movie based solely on the Brand New Day post-credit scene.

Everything pointing toward their return is currently fan theory—not confirmed Marvel canon.

But if there's one thing Marvel absolutely loves...

...it's making fans argue online for months.

Mission accomplished.

The ending leaves just enough mystery to keep every possibility alive, whether it's Tom Holland entering a new universe, Tobey making a legendary comeback, Andrew finally getting another shot, or an entirely new Spider-Man waiting in the shadows.

Until Marvel officially reveals the answer, one thing is certain:

The Multiverse isn't done with Spider-Man... not even close.

🍿 Ready to Watch Spider-Man: Brand New Day?

Reading theories is fun... but watching the movie yourself? That's a whole different experience.

Don't let social media spoil every big moment. Experience the shocking twists, emotional ending, and the mysterious post-credit scene that has Marvel fans arguing across the internet.

🎬 Watch Spider-Man: Brand New Day now on NgeFilm & SMovies in HD quality with subtitles and smooth streaming, so you can catch every hidden clue and decide for yourself:

Was Marvel teasing Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, a brand-new Spider-Man... or something even bigger?

After you've watched it, come back and join the discussion. We'd love to hear your theories—and don't forget to share this article with your fellow Spider-Man fans!